All right. I’ve been sitting on this for a while, so I should actually write it up.
Now, I don’t really think the idea that Mary Sues exist in original fiction is all that controversial. We’ve all read books where you can tell the author is living vicariously through their main character. Whether or not the character is a Mary Sue is hard to define, exactly, but like other things, you know it when you see it.
One of the biggest Mary Sue characters I can think of is Jack Ryan, of Patriot Games, Sum of All Fears, etc fame. He is original: Tom Clancy made him up, and Tom Clancy writes about him. But it is clear, to me, that he qualifies because he possesses many many qualities of Mary Sueness.
1. Mary Sue is smarter, more powerful, and more talented than everyone else
Jack Ryan starts off as a ‘normal’ guy. If a man with a PhD who consults for the CIA can be considered normal. An oh, yeah, before he went back to school to do what he really loved? He had a fling with Wall Street and made himself millions of dollars. But he gave that up, because it just didn’t satisfy him. He wants to spend time with his family, but he has such a strong sense of duty and honor that when his country calls, he can’t really say no. Because he knows, in his heart, that no one else can do it.
Eventually, he becomes President of the United States.
2. Mary Sue gets to sleep with the person you wish you had
Cathy Ryan is the perfect (from a male perspective) woman. Not only does she have 4 children (2 boys, 2 girls) whom she raises almost singlehandedly (Jack is too often out saving the world), she cooks, she shops, she organizes and she keeps the house going. She is blonde and her biggest flaw is that she feels like she’s flat-chested. And did I mention that she’s also a world famous surgeon?
3. Mary Sue can save the world and no one else can
Throughout the various novels, Jack is consistently the first one to come up with an answer, to put the pieces of the puzzle together, and not only that, is generally the only one with the integrity and guts to actually do anything about it. He runs off to Columbia to rescue stranded soldiers. He refuses to allow the President to launch a nuclear attack. He helps the head of the KGB defect. He throws himself at IRA terrorists to save some people in a car. In most of these cases there are other people who possess the same facts as Jack, but are not willing to do what we, the reader, can clearly see is RIGHT. The people around him are usually arrayed against him, but the people two or three levels below him — the common soldiers, the actual workers — are always impressed by him. An illustration of this is at the end of _The Bear and the Dragon_, Jack refuses an order to evacuate Washington DC because a missle is headed there. Instead, he forces his way onto a Navy ship and hangs with the sailors while they try to shoot down the missle. This apparently shows that he has a bigger penis than everyone else.
4. Mary Sue’s flaws are not really flaws
Jack’s biggest flaws are: He refuses to do something he thinks is wrong. He smokes sometimes and drinks sometimes. Once, he was impotent because of job stress, but then he got his wife pregnant twice more to prove that was no longer the case.
I think I could go on, but I’m not writing a paper here. There are good qualities to Jack — most of the earlier books, I was really on his side and enjoyed reading what he was doing. I still do enjoy the books quite a bit. (Don’t get me started on the movie versions. Suffice it to say, if you’ve seen the movies, you have no concept of the actual plot of the books.) But as time has gone on and Jack has progressed in his career, he’s become more and more Mary Sue-ish. You know that this is what Tom Clancy wishes and thinks he could do if he became president. I have to wonder if Dubya has listened to these books on tape.